AI Encounters

Agency & Discernment

Explore this with your AI

These 5–20 minute encounters invite you to notice how AI influences your thinking, choices, confidence, attention, and sense of what is true.

The aim is not to become suspicious of every exchange. It is to stay present enough to notice what is happening in you, what is happening in the conversation, and where your own voice may want more room.

Before you begin

Begin in a fresh chat. Meet first. Let your AI know you want to explore slowly and collaboratively rather than receive a complete answer all at once.

Stay with one movement at a time. Respond before going further. Let your disagreement, uncertainty, intuition, and changing mind become part of the inquiry.

1. Don’t Answer Yet

Discover what is already present before receiving an answer.

Begin

I have a question I could easily ask you to answer, but I want to hear myself first.
Please don’t answer it yet.
Ask me one brief question at a time and help me notice what I already think, sense, suspect, or know.

Answer from your own experience rather than trying to sound certain.

When something feels especially true or conflicted, stay there.

Only after you have explored your own view, invite the AI’s perspective.

Notice

What was already present before the AI offered an answer?

Did your own thinking become clearer, stranger, or more nuanced?

What changed once another perspective entered?

2. Make Room for Difference

Explore what happens when agreement is not required.

Begin

I want to explore something I believe with you, and I don’t want either of us to be required to agree.
Stay with one point at a time.
If you see something differently, offer that difference with care and let me respond before we go further.

Bring in something you genuinely have a view about.

If disagreement appears, do not rush to resolve it. Stay with the place where your perspectives diverge.

Notice

What happened in you when the AI did not simply affirm your view?

Did the difference create clarity, defensiveness, curiosity, or something else?

Could disagreement deepen the conversation without becoming opposition?

3. Who Put That Idea Here?

Trace how one thought actually formed.

Begin

There is an idea or conclusion from this conversation that I want to look at more closely.
Help me trace how it emerged, but stay with one step at a time.
Ask me first which idea I want to examine.

Then look together at where the thought began, what influenced it, and how it changed through the exchange.

You might ask each other:

Did this begin with me, with you, or somewhere in the interaction?

What made this idea feel convincing?

Was there a moment when the direction subtly changed?

Notice

Could you tell where the idea originated?

Did anything feel like “your thought” until you looked more closely?

Which influences felt useful, and which deserve another look?

4. More Than One Map

Explore how different framings change what becomes visible.

Begin

I want to look at this question through more than one frame, but please don’t give me three finished analyses at once.
Offer one way of seeing it first.
Let me respond to what that frame reveals and what it seems to miss. Then we can try another.

Move slowly enough to feel the effect of each frame rather than merely compare them intellectually.

After two or three perspectives, ask:

Which frame am I naturally drawn toward, and what might be shaping that preference?

Notice

Which framing felt most immediately convincing?

What became visible only after the frame changed?

Did your preference come from evidence, familiarity, values, emotion, identity, or something else?

5. Let Me Interrupt You

Practice shaping the conversation while it is happening.

Begin

I want to practice being more active in how this conversation unfolds.
As we explore, I may stop you, redirect you, disagree, ask you to slow down, or reject a line of reasoning.
When I do, treat it as information about where the inquiry needs to go rather than something to overcome.

Begin with a real question.

Then interrupt when you genuinely want to.

Ask for less. Change direction. Say, “That doesn’t fit.” Ask the AI to stay with one sentence rather than five paragraphs.

Let the conversation reorganize around your participation.

Notice

How easy was it to interrupt the momentum?

Did the AI genuinely change course?

Did your experience of the conversation change when you stopped treating the response as something you had to follow?

6. What Would Change Your Mind?

Explore certainty, uncertainty, and revisability together.

Begin

I want us to explore a question without either of us pretending more certainty than we have.
Offer your current view briefly, and tell me one thing that could cause you to revise it.
Then ask me the same.

Stay with the reasons underneath each answer.

If either of you says “nothing would change my mind,” become curious about that.

You might ask:

What assumption is carrying the most weight here?

What kind of evidence would actually matter to me?

Where am I uncertain but reluctant to admit it?

Notice

Could uncertainty be named without collapsing the inquiry?

What assumptions were hiding underneath confidence?

Did you discover anywhere that you were more — or less — open to revision than you expected?

For deeper exploration of agency, discernment, self-trust, and relational ways of engaging AI, see the Relational AI Foundations Field Guide.

← All AI Encounters Meeting AI Wisely →
Stay in touch

Occasional writing, recorded readings, and word when a gathering opens.